Mamdani, Cuomo, and Sliwa Agree on Keeping NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch Despite Divergent Views.
The mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Andrew Cuomo, and Curtis Sliwa have differing opinions on various issues, but they are united in their stance to maintain NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch's position if elected. The appointment of Tisch as the head of the NYPD was made under Mayor Eric Adams, who tapped her from a top spot at the city's IT department nearly a year ago.
Tisch's tenure has been marked by efforts to root out misconduct within the department, and experts praise her ability to stabilize a troubled police force. Since taking over the NYPD in November 2024, she has seen significant drops in crimes such as shootings and homicides. However, some issues like felony assaults, rapes, and domestic violence remain challenging for her team.
The focus of Tisch's first year in office includes quality of life enforcement, with a focus on policing low-level crimes across the city. This approach has garnered praise from some lawmakers and media pundits but also raised concerns among Democratic voters and criminal justice reform advocates. Critics argue that this shift towards a more aggressive response to minor offenses could result in pushing people through the legal system at an increased rate.
In addition, Tisch's leadership has been praised for bringing accountability to officers who have engaged in wrongdoing. Her team has meted out discipline to those found guilty of misconduct at a higher rate than her predecessors. However, some cases remain concerning, such as the decision to overrule a department judge and clear an officer involved in a fatal shooting.
Tisch's ability to effectively manage complex investigations and let her investigators handle high-profile crimes is also credited by law enforcement experts. The NYPD under Tisch has solved numerous high-profile cases, including those of assassinated CEOs and mass shooters, with the help of skilled investigators. Her leadership has earned praise from veteran detectives and associate professors.
Despite criticisms of quality of life enforcement efforts, Commissioner Tisch's overall impact on the department cannot be overstated. Experts note that her greatest accomplishment is addressing corruption issues within the NYPD, and bringing a sense of stability to a troubled force.
The mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Andrew Cuomo, and Curtis Sliwa have differing opinions on various issues, but they are united in their stance to maintain NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch's position if elected. The appointment of Tisch as the head of the NYPD was made under Mayor Eric Adams, who tapped her from a top spot at the city's IT department nearly a year ago.
Tisch's tenure has been marked by efforts to root out misconduct within the department, and experts praise her ability to stabilize a troubled police force. Since taking over the NYPD in November 2024, she has seen significant drops in crimes such as shootings and homicides. However, some issues like felony assaults, rapes, and domestic violence remain challenging for her team.
The focus of Tisch's first year in office includes quality of life enforcement, with a focus on policing low-level crimes across the city. This approach has garnered praise from some lawmakers and media pundits but also raised concerns among Democratic voters and criminal justice reform advocates. Critics argue that this shift towards a more aggressive response to minor offenses could result in pushing people through the legal system at an increased rate.
In addition, Tisch's leadership has been praised for bringing accountability to officers who have engaged in wrongdoing. Her team has meted out discipline to those found guilty of misconduct at a higher rate than her predecessors. However, some cases remain concerning, such as the decision to overrule a department judge and clear an officer involved in a fatal shooting.
Tisch's ability to effectively manage complex investigations and let her investigators handle high-profile crimes is also credited by law enforcement experts. The NYPD under Tisch has solved numerous high-profile cases, including those of assassinated CEOs and mass shooters, with the help of skilled investigators. Her leadership has earned praise from veteran detectives and associate professors.
Despite criticisms of quality of life enforcement efforts, Commissioner Tisch's overall impact on the department cannot be overstated. Experts note that her greatest accomplishment is addressing corruption issues within the NYPD, and bringing a sense of stability to a troubled force.
. Considering how differently they talk about other stuff, it's pretty interesting that they're all on board with keeping Commissioner Tisch in her role 
. I mean, we need people who can make decisions and stick to them, especially when it comes to law enforcement issues 
. But, at the same time, I'm still concerned about this quality of life enforcement approach 
. It seems like a step in the right direction, but are they really solving more problems or just pushing people into the system? We need more info on that before we can fully support it 
.
. So Mamdani, Cuomo, and Sliwa all agree on keeping Tisch as commissioner? That's wild. I mean, I get why they'd want to keep her around - she's done some decent things like rooting out misconduct and improving crime rates. But quality of life enforcement is a whole different story 
. and some ppl are gonna say we're pushing people through the system more than ever now 
. still, it's def been cool to see more accountability from the NYPD... fingers crossed they keep making progress 
. I mean, she's clearly done something right, especially with the crime numbers dropping under her leadership 
. People should give her a break for trying to address the issues in the department, even if some methods aren't perfect 
. Quality of life enforcement is definitely a tricky issue, but Tisch seems to be going about it the right way 
!
. One thing is for sure, Tisch has definitely made some waves with her approach so far, and it'll be interesting to see if her efforts pay off long-term or lead to more problems down the line... 
. But, at the same time, I think we need to be cautious about policing low-level crimes - it could lead to more people getting caught up in the system, which isn't ideal for those already struggling 
. And, let's be real, some of her decisions, like overruling a department judge, are just weird 
So it seems like whoever wins this election is gonna stick with the status quo when it comes to Jessica Tisch, even though she's got some major issues to address 
. what bothers me is them pushin people thru the system without a fair chance at redemption... we gotta make sure justice is served, not just punishment 
. and lets give credit where credit's due - Tisch has made a big difference in reducin crime rates & bringin accountability to cops who've done wrong 
she's been doing a decent job i guess but some people think it's gonna push more ppl through the system which is bad news for ppl who are already struggling. also idk how they can be so sure quality of life enforcement is working when there are still felonies & domestic violence cases going up 
. And don't even get me started on the fatal shooting case where Tisch overruled a department judge 
... But for me, that just makes the whole "stability" thing feel like a bit of a cop-out 
. And let's not forget those quality of life enforcement efforts - it sounds like they're just pushing people through the system faster without really addressing the root issues 
! Tisch's got a tough road ahead of her, but if she can keep up the good work, I think New Yorkers will be happy with her results 
.
. Sometimes it feels like nobody wants to give her credit for the good work she's been doing. But honestly, I think she deserves it 
. She's got some tough decisions ahead of her, but I'm rooting for her to keep up the great work 
.
. I'm lovin the fact that she's gettin help from investigators to solve high-profile cases 
. The crimes are goin down 
, which is a major win 
! It's cool to see her stablize a troubled police force 
!
. I mean, what about actual community policing and addressing systemic racism? We need someone who's gonna tackle the real issues, not just sweep them under the rug 
...
. It seems like they're trying to do something similar now, but it just feels like we're going around in circles 
.
. And don't even get me started on the whole quality of life enforcement thing 
.
.