Quebec's Lake Rouge vanished – but was it a freak natural event or caused by human actions?

Canada's wilderness is rapidly losing its tranquility, as scientists struggle to unravel the mystery behind the sudden disappearance of Lake Rouge in Quebec. The lake, which had been around for years, vanished overnight, leaving behind a vast expanse of mud and dead fish.

Experts have dubbed this phenomenon an "outburst flood," where a lake suddenly drains into another body of water. While such events are rare, Lake Rouge's case has left many scratching their heads, with some even questioning whether human activities might be to blame.

Theories abound, but so do contradictions. The Quebec government has concluded that the lake's disappearance was natural, citing a study from 2004 that suggested there is little chance of waterways being altered by high peak flows if only half or less of the forest in a given watershed is disturbed by logging or wildfires.

However, some scientists argue that human activities could have played a role. Logan Alila, a University of British Columbia hydrologist, notes that repeated wildfires and clear-cutting can alter groundwater levels, leading to increased runoff and erosion. The loss of tree cover can also make the soil more water-repellent, exacerbating the problem.

A similar case was reported in 1974, when a small lake in Alberta vanished within hours after being disturbed by a fisherman's boot. This incident highlights how rapidly changing landscapes can lead to unexpected events.

Yet another example is seen in western Canada, where the town of Quesnel has been sliding towards the Fraser River for nearly three decades due to increased groundwater levels. A landslide on the Chilcotin River in 2024 also created a natural dam, backing up water into an impromptu lake.

While scientists disagree over the causes behind these events, one thing is clear: human activities are having a profound impact on Canada's wilderness. Climate change, wildfires, and deforestation are all contributing factors that are altering the natural landscape at an unprecedented rate.

As Chief Irene Neeposh of Waswanipi Cree community urged, "Call me if you have a lake that drains, right? Nobody knows what to do in this type of situation." The disappearance of Lake Rouge has left many scrambling for answers, but it also serves as a stark reminder of the importance of preserving our natural world.
 
🤔 so like i dont think we should be too quick to blame humans for lake rouge disappearing or anything...ive seen vids of them saying its "natural" and all thats true but im not convinced...i mean, climate change is a thing and fires are getting more intense etc...maybe theres some link there? 🌿🔥 and i feel bad for logan alila trying to sound the alarm about human impact on water levels...hes just doing his job, you know? 🔬 meanwhile, im all about that preservation life, we gotta take care of our nature and stuff...but can we really say weve got it figured out yet? 🤷‍♂️ still waiting for those answers, tbh 😐
 
man i was just out hiking in alberta last weekend and saw like 5 different rivers that were all swollen from wildfires 🌳💧 and now this happens with lake rouge... it's crazy how quickly things can change in nature, right? i mean we're always talking about climate change and how it's affecting the environment but it's actually happening right in front of us 🌪️. and yeah, deforestation is a huge part of it - my uncle was a logger for years and he told me that when they clear-cut trees, the soil just gets all compacted and water-repellent, which can lead to huge runoff events like this 🤯.
 
Ugh 🤕 this is so sad... I mean, can you even imagine waking up and finding out your lake just vanished overnight? It's like, what even is going on with the environment right now? 🌎 It seems like human activities are having such a huge impact on our planet, and it's devastating to see. Climate change, wildfires, deforestation... it all adds up to these crazy natural disasters happening left and right. I'm just so worried about the future of our planet, you know? 😕 And I feel for that Chief Irene Neeposh, she's right, what do we even do when a lake just disappears? It's like, we need more answers, more solutions... 🤔
 
I'm low-key concerned about all these weird lake disappearances 🤯. Like, I get that climate change and deforestation are big issues, but can't we just slow down on the whole " destroying the environment" thing? 🙄 It's not like scientists haven't been studying the effects of human activity on waterways for decades.

I'm also a bit tired of people using Lake Rouge as an excuse to say "see, humans are causing all this!" without doing their own research 🤔. I mean, sure, human activities might be contributing factors, but can't we acknowledge that nature's got its own weird ways too? Maybe there's more to it than just "we're causing it" or "it's natural"? 🌿

It's great that people are talking about this stuff, but can we also talk about what WE can do to prevent these kinds of disasters from happening in the first place? Like, how can we slow down on logging and wildfires without completely stopping human progress? 💡
 
omg like i was reading about lake rouge in canada and its literally mind blown idk what's going on with the science behind it but it feels like humans r messing up the environment so bad climate change deforestation wildfires... everything is affecting these lakes and rivers and its super scary 🌿😱 i feel like we should be doing more to protect our nature lol can u imagine not knowing how to handle a lake that just drains away overnight? 😂 chief irene neeposh said it best call her if u have a lake problem lol anyway its def a reminder to take care of our planet 🌎💚
 
I'm getting so frustrated with these outburst floods 🤯! One minute there's a lake, the next it's just mud and dead fish everywhere. And people are still debating whether it's human activities or not? Like, come on, we've known about deforestation and wildfires for decades and now we're just starting to see the effects? 🌳 The numbers don't lie, humans are causing irreparable damage to our environment and it's only a matter of time before something like this happens again. We need to take responsibility for our actions and start preserving our wilderness instead of just reacting to it after it's happened.
 
I'm skeptical about these outburst floods 🤔. I mean, think about it, lakes just... vanish overnight? It sounds like something straight out of a sci-fi movie 🚀. And all this talk about human activities altering groundwater levels and soil permeability is just too convenient 🙄. What's next? Are we gonna say that the lake was drained by aliens 🛸? I'm not buying it, folks. I need concrete evidence before I start jumping on the "human activities are ruining our wilderness" bandwagon 🚫. And what about all these reported cases of lakes disappearing in the 70s and 80s? Was that just a coincidence too? I don't think so 🔮. We need to be careful not to jump to conclusions here 👀.
 
omg like i'm so worried about canada's wilderness 🌳😨 lake rouge disappearing overnight is literally insane... can't believe scientists are still debating whether it's human activities or not 🤔 some people think logging and wildfires can alter groundwater levels, which is a major concern 📉 deforestation and climate change are already wreaking havoc on the environment, now this? 🌪️ i'm all for preserving our natural world, but what's being done to stop these disasters from happening in the first place?! 🤷‍♀️ we need more research and action ASAP 💚
 
omg u no i was out w/ my fam last summer n we went 4 a hike n lake rouge was literally right there in front of us n then suddenly its like POOF 🤯 they say its not human activity but im like what if ? my friend's cousin works @ the university n he said that logan alila guy is totes saying it could be cuz of wildfires & clear-cutting... i dont know tho maybe its just a crazy natural thing? btw has anyone heard about lake rouge being back? 🤔
 
Back
Top