A century and a half of Independence Day celebrations have done little to reconcile America's troubled past. The upcoming Semiquincentennial commemorations will undoubtedly be filled with platitudes about unity, pride, and national identity. But beneath the pomp and circumstance lies a more complex reality – one that acknowledges the flag has long been a symbol of starkly opposing ideals.
The American flag was not always taken seriously as a national symbol until 1814, when Congress finally settled on its modern template. Yet, during and after the Civil War, it was seen as a source of division rather than unity. Southerners burned the flag, ripped it down, and spat on it – a stark contrast to the reverence with which it's now regarded.
The notion that America has always had a singular unifying narrative is a myth. The country's birth in 1776 was contested, its 100th birthday was marked by a conciliatory narrative that painted veterans as noble brothers, while the "emancipationist vision of Civil War memory" faded, replaced by the romance of Reconstruction.
The 1976 U.S. Bicentennial, which took place during a time of racial tensions and social upheaval, also privileged heritage over history. Native Americans were asked to commemorate what was for many a day of mourning, and American democracy is still grappling with deep structural inequalities that threaten its fabric.
Today's Republican and Democratic patriotism are worlds apart, and the sense of pride that once bound them together has worn thin. Pundits have openly despaired of America's "identity crisis" and called for a fresh national story to rally people to a new trajectory.
But there is no single unifying narrative that can serve an inclusive, patriotic identity. The country's history is complex and multifaceted, and attempting to forge a new heritage only risks perpetuating the same old myths and biases.
Instead of reaching for a new half-truth, it's time to acknowledge the flag's troubled past and support a ruling coalition that acknowledges its complexities while fighting for what it should be – a symbol of freedom, justice, and equality for all. History offers motley warnings, reality-checks, and sober inspirations – not a master narrative.
The grand narrative of America as a "shining city on a hill" has lost its use. It's time to take the broken participation trophy of American exceptionalism off the mantle and recognize that there is more than enough curiosity in this country to acknowledge all American histories, in all their differences.
The American flag was not always taken seriously as a national symbol until 1814, when Congress finally settled on its modern template. Yet, during and after the Civil War, it was seen as a source of division rather than unity. Southerners burned the flag, ripped it down, and spat on it – a stark contrast to the reverence with which it's now regarded.
The notion that America has always had a singular unifying narrative is a myth. The country's birth in 1776 was contested, its 100th birthday was marked by a conciliatory narrative that painted veterans as noble brothers, while the "emancipationist vision of Civil War memory" faded, replaced by the romance of Reconstruction.
The 1976 U.S. Bicentennial, which took place during a time of racial tensions and social upheaval, also privileged heritage over history. Native Americans were asked to commemorate what was for many a day of mourning, and American democracy is still grappling with deep structural inequalities that threaten its fabric.
Today's Republican and Democratic patriotism are worlds apart, and the sense of pride that once bound them together has worn thin. Pundits have openly despaired of America's "identity crisis" and called for a fresh national story to rally people to a new trajectory.
But there is no single unifying narrative that can serve an inclusive, patriotic identity. The country's history is complex and multifaceted, and attempting to forge a new heritage only risks perpetuating the same old myths and biases.
Instead of reaching for a new half-truth, it's time to acknowledge the flag's troubled past and support a ruling coalition that acknowledges its complexities while fighting for what it should be – a symbol of freedom, justice, and equality for all. History offers motley warnings, reality-checks, and sober inspirations – not a master narrative.
The grand narrative of America as a "shining city on a hill" has lost its use. It's time to take the broken participation trophy of American exceptionalism off the mantle and recognize that there is more than enough curiosity in this country to acknowledge all American histories, in all their differences.
️
like, those southerners burning the flag during civil war wasnt exactly a symbolic act of unity...and what about native americans being asked to commemorate their own day of mourning during the 1976 bicentennial? that sounds pretty messed up. and now they're trying to create this new narrative of freedom and justice for all? idk, it just seems like another example of how americas history is always getting watered down 
. Like, we know the flag has been a symbol of division too, right? Southerners literally hated it back in the day . And don't even get me started on how Native Americans were treated during the 1976 Bicentennial 
. It's time to stop pretending like America is this perfect, unified country and just face the messy truth 
. Let's acknowledge the flag's troubled past and work towards something more inclusive and equal for everyone 
.
. We're still dealing with systemic inequalities and racism, so it's time to acknowledge that our flag isn't just a symbol of freedom and justice... it's also a reminder of all the ways we've fallen short 
. Instead of trying to come up with some new, inclusive narrative, let's just be real about our complexities and try to do better 
. And honestly, who needs a "shining city on a hill" when we can strive for something more like a "city of imperfect progress"? 
. We gotta learn from the past, not try to erase it or make a new myth around it. What's wrong with acknowledging that America ain't all sunshine and rainbows? 
. We can't just focus on unity and pride without also recognizing the divisions that have shaped our country over time 
.
. Southerners burning it down, ripping it apart, and spitting on it during the Civil War is pretty wild stuff 
. And what about Native Americans being asked to commemorate their own loss of sovereignty? 
. Our country's history is multifaceted, and that's what makes it so interesting 
.
. Let's learn from our mistakes and use them as opportunities for growth 
.
.
. The flag is literally supposed to be a symbol of unity but honestly it just represents so many different things to people. I mean, who thought it was a good idea to make the same symbol that Southerners were burning and ripping down during the Civil War? 
It's like we're trying to erase all the pain and trauma from our history instead of facing it head-on.
.
. Like, let's acknowledge that our country has always been built on problematic ideals and that we need to work towards creating a more equal society 
. We can't keep pretending like everything is all sunshine and rainbows when our history is so messy and flawed 
. Let's acknowledge the pain and struggles of marginalized communities, Native Americans, and others who've been left out of the narrative 
. It's not about finding a new "unifying" story, but about being honest with ourselves about what we're trying to celebrate 
. And don't even get me started on Native Americans being asked to commemorate a day when it was basically a national mourning for them 
.
.
especially when it comes to Native Americans, slavery, and segregation. Trying to gloss over that or pretend it didn't happen won't make it better 
The flag has been both a symbol of unity and division throughout history - it's crazy to think that some people actually spit on it during the Civil War 
.
we can't just keep repeating the same old myths and expect everything to magically get better. instead, let's acknowledge our country's complicated past and work towards a more inclusive future where everyone has a seat at the table 
. 
. And now, with the Republican and Democratic parties having such different views on everything, it's hard to find common ground 
.
And don't even get me started on how weird it is that Native Americans were asked to celebrate a day when for them it was probably more like a national mourning day. 
